Skip to content
BusinessesGrow
AJ's NY Pizzeria, Manhattan, KS
Eat & DrinkLocal GemFamily Favorite

AJ's NY Pizzeria

301 Poyntz Ave · Manhattan, KS

Why you should go…

AJ's NY Pizzeria brings New York style pizza to Poyntz Avenue in downtown Manhattan, with a sister shop in Topeka. You can order a whole pie or grab a slice, and salads round out the menu. The pizzeria also handles catering and takes orders online and through its own Android and iOS apps, which makes it an easy stop before or after exploring downtown.

  • #pizza
  • #new york style pizza
  • #pizza by the slice
  • #downtown manhattan

Good to know

General eat & drink guidance

Habits that pay off across this whole category, not rules for this one venue. Always check the official site for the specifics.

  • Go early or go late

    The simplest way around a wait at a popular room is to sit down before the rush or after it.

  • Reservations open on a schedule

    Where bookings are taken, tables tend to be released a set number of days in advance, often at a fixed hour.

  • Menus move with the season

    Treat any dish you read about online as a maybe, not a promise, especially anything local and seasonal.

  • Ask what the place is known for

    Staff will point you at the thing worth ordering faster than any list will.

What's around here?

The closest stops to AJ's NY Pizzeria, ordered by straight-line distance. A few more like it, plus some different kinds of fun so you can build a full day.

  • Eat & Drink
    Foodie Favorite

    Bourbon & Baker

    $25–$50

    Share small plates of Southern and Midwestern food and sip from a long bourbon list at this downtown Poyntz Avenue spot.

    Right next doorMore like this

  • Attractions
    Quirky Fun

    Manhatchet

    $25–$50

    Throw axes in lanes inside the historic Woolworth Building in downtown Manhattan, with food from downtown restaurants served in house.

    Right next doorSwitch it up: Attractions

  • Shopping
    Local Gem

    The Boutique MHK

    Free

    A locally owned downtown Manhattan boutique for women's and baby clothing, gifts and K-State gameday looks.

    Right next doorSwitch it up: Shopping

  • Eat & Drink
    Foodie Favorite

    Tallgrass Tap House

    Under $25

    An 11,000-square-foot downtown brewpub pouring its own rotating craft beers, with a seasonal rooftop patio.

    Right next doorMore like this

  • Shopping
    Local Gem

    SNW Gallery & Custom Frames

    Free

    Browse paintings, glass, jewelry and estate art by Kansas and regional artists, and order custom framing on site in downtown Manhattan.

    Right next doorSwitch it up: Shopping

  • Eat & Drink
    Foodie Favorite

    The Chef Cafe

    Under $25

    Order frittatas, PB&J pancakes and Chef Blend coffee at a downtown Manhattan breakfast and brunch spot on South 4th Street.

    Right next doorMore like this